Monday, October 6, 2008
Final thoughts of Nick
Word Count: 248
Sunday, October 5, 2008
Impacting yet, Solemn......
Amir and Farid’s return to the orphanage stirred my anger as well, when Farid was furious with the orphanage manager for selling orphans to the Talib officer. Even if Farid was intimidated for his life, this gave him no reason to sacrifice his scruples for such petty thing money under ANY circumstance. This, combined with the events at the stadium showed me. How truly the brutality of the Taliban was during the time. Up till the moment with the Taliban and Sohrab in the room, did I realize that it was Assef. Though it was harsh of the punishment that Assef gave, I too with Amir felt that it was a nesscary evil to quench his soul.
I was deeply shaken with the attempt of suicide of Sohrab at the apartment, and I was surprised how much it touched me on an emotional level. I was very impressed on how well Hosseini was able to build up a relationship on nothing. To feel the empathy of how devastating it would truly be if Sohrab would take his own life. The corruption within the country for a simple thing (which actually wasn’t that simple) such as adoption gave a great insight into how other countries polices would work. I generally really enjoyed this book on the level of detail and emotion brought into it. Though, I (personally) was unsatisfied by the ending and felt it could have been stronger. It none the less left a solemn yet impressionable ending.
Word count: 248
Section Three Thoughts
I like how as the book progressed, the Baba and Amir’s characters got better. I also enjoyed the way Hosseini would add in memorable phrases about the aspects of the story. Such as “Blood is a powerful thing,” “When you tell a lie, you steal a man’s right to the truth,” and “There is a way to be good again.” These phrases and others arose at times throughout the book that would reveal a new truth behind their meaning or to a greater magnitude than previously thought.
Word Count: 242
The End
This book was absolutely beautiful. I felt it captured so many different emotions in it, while still keeping on the basis of the storyline. The last section pulled me in and shocked me. I felt that when Amir went to find Sohrab, he would find himself, but it was almost as if it was the complete opposite. At first, Sohrab and he began to bond, and I found it so touching and, almost odd in a way. But before Soraya, the only person Amir ever opened up to was Hassan, because no one else gave him the chance. But the book took several twists. I did not anticipate Amir ever being able to take Sohrab back to America with him. When he found out that he had gained the visa, it filled me with so much joy, and then all of a sudden, the author ripped it out from underneath me when Amir found Sohrab in the bathroom like he did. But I have to admit, after all of the emotional ups and downs of the last section, I felt that the ending was a very big let down. Part of me almost wanted Sohrab to become like Hassan, and warm right up to Soraya and Amir, but when he went back and was their silent child. It was hard to feel that the book was truly ending. But I absolutely loved at the end when Amir said he would chase the kite for Sohrab and said “for you a thousand times over.” This grabbed my heart and pulled it right into the book. All in all, I am very glad I read this book.
Word Count: 275
Section 3
First off, I’d like to say how much I enjoyed the book. It was a great read and kept me interested the whole time, there were no slow boring sections, to skim through, but most importantly, a good ending. I’m really happy that Amir finally told Soraya and her parents about his dark past and got the monkey off of his chest. I am also not surprised at all that Rahim Khan knew about Hassan the whole time, but I am a little disappointed we never got much closure from him, since he just disappeared at the end. I’m finally happy with Amir, for facing Assef in that epic show down, and saving Sohrab. Amir has finally found redemption for his past wrongs and can live with himself. I’m glad the story ended with Amir and Sohrab flying kites and connecting with each other for the first time.
All of that said there were some pretty disturbing things about this section. First off the mass execution by stoning was brutal and must have been beyond horrible to watch. To me this really shows the depth of inhumanity that the Taliban had, and makes me glad that we helped their country be rid of them. Second Sohrab trying to kill himself, was completely unexpected. I thought he would be upset after Amir told him he would have to live in an orphanage again, but to the extent of killing himself. I thought he would want to live no matter what, after all he had been through to get to this point.
All in all I’m glad that I choose this book to read, and I think I might pick A Thousand Splendid Suns next time.
Word count 286
Section Three
Another surprise in this section was when Assef was the Taliban who met with Amir and killed the people earlier in the day. He is just one messed up guy, first raping Hassan, killing people in the name of God, then taking Hassan’s son and turning him into a “servant”. But was Amir walked out injured but alive from the fight, Sohrab in hand, I was happy Assef got what he deserved.
Overall, I enjoyed this book and I am defiantly going to get A Thousand Splendid Suns and read that one too!
word count: 226
Friday, October 3, 2008
Section Three (228-End)
One part that absolutely shocked me though was when it was revealed The Talib was Assef. When I found out, I first thought, “No way!” But then I felt stupid for not realizing it. Assef is just a messed up man though. First he rapes Hassan when they were children, then later on he keeps Hassan’s son as a “servant”. I was so glad when Amir and Assef got in their fight. Amir did deserve to get beat up after going many, many years without confessing what he saw Assef do to Hassan. But when Sohrab hit Assef in the eye with his sling shot, I was excited. Although it was very descriptive and disgusting, Assef somewhat got what he deserved. I personally think he deserved to die though. I thought Sohrab was dead when I found out he was in the hospital for cutting himself. I was so sad because I wanted him to grow up to be a happy little boy in America.
Although Sohrab did end up surviving and moving to America with Amir and Soraya, I still was disappointed in the ending. I wish Sohrab would realize he’s safe in America and he can be happy, but I guess since The Kite Runner is about real life in Afghanistan, so it needed a realistic ending. Overall I really enjoyed this book though, and it’s now one of my favorites.
Word Count: 262
Sunday, September 28, 2008
Nick's critiques
This section changed a lot and raised a couple of questions. First of all, does Soraya have a unibrow? It says, “She had thick black eyebrows that touched in the middle like the arched wings of a flying bird…” Okay. Gross. Why would Amir find that attractive? Also, why does he call her “My Swap Meet Princess?” I dislike how Hosseini just leaves out a large portion of Amir’s life after Hassan leaves. Suddenly, he’s 18, and now 20. Did I blink and miss all of those years? He must have filled up that entire book Rahim Khan gave him at some point. Whatever happened to him? He just dropped out of the story for a bit of this particular section with no explanation about where he went. Another thing that bothered me is the unclearness of the whole leaving home ordeal. I’m sure none of us here are majors in Afgani history so how does Hosseinni expect us to know what happened? I don’t understand any of the smuggling operations either. I do enjoy how Hosseinni will write a sentence that isn’t grammatically correct but I can still understand it, such as, “Took Baba home.” and “Panic.” However, I don’t like how all these Afgani words are used in the book. I could care less to learn these words. I forget them faster than I read them. Hosseinni has to translate them in the next word anyways so what is the point? This section did have a lot more emotion in it. It made me happy when Baba said that Amir getting married made him the most proud he has ever been. Baba was finally happy with his son.
Word Count: 277
Section Two Thoughts
When Amir and Baba flee Kabul, I started to gain a greater appreciation for Baba. I previously thought Rahim Khan would have been a much more suitable father for Amir; but everything Baba does starting in chapter ten with them escaping up to his death in chapter thirteen, I thought brought out the better fathering skills in Baba. I really enjoyed getting to know Baba better in these chapters.
I had been wondering about Rahim Khan the whole time reading about Amir being a published writer in America. When he finally was brought back to our attention in chapter fourteen, I figured he had just wanted to catch up with Amir, offer condolences for Baba, and see Amir before he died. Chapter sixteen, seventeen, and eighteen completely blindsided me. I have to give credit to Khaled Hosseini for his writing in these chapters, because it seemed as if I felt the emotions as they struck Amir with every new word spoken by Rahim Khan. I also think it is very interesting that earlier, Rahim Khan and Amir had spoken of irony in Amir’s story, but now it was Rahim delivering the irony (and he was speaking of real life in the book).
Word Count: 331
ahhh, too much to say....so here's more on Part II!
The return to
word count: 192
whoo boy, its getting interesting...
Okay, to first begin...Amir needs to grow up. By betraying his best friend out of his own hurt and plight, and then having to cry and feel bad about it and THEN getting him kicked out of his home! When it was originally his fault for not manning up to it in the first place, This guy is R-I-D-I-C-U-L-O-U-S. Whoo, anyway...besides that, It was very interesting to see how
Ah yes, the classic ladey da, lovey dovey stuff... Though sentimentally touching as it may be. I was greatly surprised and disliked how much the traditional courting system that was set up in
word count: 243
Section 2
This book just keeps on getting better and better. This section was full of surprises and my feelings changed rapidly through the section. My feelings towards Amir went from complete hatred when he forced out Ali and Hassan, to sympathetic when Baba died. This section really showed us who Baba really was from him willing to die for the woman in the truck, to helping Amir get married in his last days of life. I still can’t believe that Hassan is Amir’s brother. Had Amir known I think he would have helped in the alley that day, and it could have avoided all the childhood problems that Amir had with Hassan. My feelings have changed toward Baba too, now that I know that he had Hassan as an illegitimate child. In one respect it better justifies his attachment to Hassan and helps me better understand his actions, but at the same time it makes think down upon him for not telling Amir, even when Baba knew he was going to die. I’m glad that Amir finally went back to Afghanistan (well Pakistan so far) and saw Rahim Khan. He definitely has some unresolved issues that he needs to take care of so he can have some peace in his life. I’m glad that Amir has a wife and is living a great life in America, but I hope that he takes this opportunity to right the wrongs of his past. I look forward to reading the rest of the book.
Section Two
After reading this section, I’m unsure exactly how I feel towards Amir’s character. This section starts off with Amir framing Hassan for stealing his money and his watch, and getting Hassan and Ali to leave. I thought of this as the lowest thing he could’ve possibly done, but at the same time, he also seemed almost justified in his actions. It was a very odd situation, and I just remember the part at the end of this chapter where he sat in his room, watching Hassan leave in the rain. Then, I thought the part about Amir and Baba being stowed away in a truck and going to a different country was really spectacular. The author had yet to really give us an idea of Baba’s character, and in this section, through the way Baba saved the woman on the truck, and acted towards Amir growing up; it really developed Baba’s character. I found it to be almost foreshadowing when Baba started treating Amir better once Hassan and Ali had left. I loved the development of Amir’s character between him and Soraya, and the whole shebang with the wedding and Baba’s cancer. It was so emotional in so many ways that it just reeled you into the story. When Amir went back to Pakistan to find Rahim Khan, I knew that something was up, and when he found out that Hassan was his illegitimate brother I was stunned. But I honestly have continued reading already and simply love the way the book is turning out.
Word Count: 255
Thursday, September 25, 2008
Section Two (pgs. 101-227)
There were also some things I was happy about in the book though. I was really excited when Amir heard from Rahim Khan. Personally, Rahim Khan is my favorite character in the book. He seems like a very nice, forgiving person that has a good head on their shoulders. It was sad when Khaled Hosseini described how sick Rahim was. I was so surprised when I read that Amir and Hassan were half brothers. It kind of cleared up why Baba was so protective of Hassan though. I was also really happy when Amir went to go find his nephew. I thought at first he’d just leave and go back to America, but he finally made a good decision in the book. I hope that in the end, Amir finds his nephew and takes him back to America to live with him and Soraya.
Word Count- 300
Section Two
When the time came, in America for Amir to marry and Baba passed away, I felt all of the emotions with them, I was happy then I was sad. The author let Amir be on his own with his wife, like Baba said many years ago, Amir would have to fight his own battles, and he would have to later. When Rahim Khan calls and asks Amir to come visit his, as he is dying, Amir’s whole past comes rushing back to him, even though he worked so hard to forget it. When Amir gets there, he learns the truth about how Hassan and he were really blood related and how he was tragically killed but still loved Amir and wanted to see him. Amir does the right thing and goes to get his orphaned son or really nephew. The author wanted to show us, the reader how much Amir regretted how he treated Hassan but he can do right to go get his son.
word count: 270
Monday, September 22, 2008
Section One Thoughts
After finishing this section, I guess I was not that far off. I was wrong about the winter of 1975 being the start of war since the only violence of the sort was the coup d’état in chapter five, which was not to the magnitude I had expected. But Hassan’s sacrifice is just in a different form than I had expected it. Once chapter six started mentioning the kite fighting tournaments and the life-changing winter of 1975 that Amir had been leading up to, I was fairly confused. Amir spoke of the kite fighting as joyous times and a companionship with Hassan. Whereas the references to the winter of 1975 were all melancholy and filled with regret. These two concepts did not seem to have any relation to each before the tournament. I was still in the dark when Hassan recited the phrase that haunted Amir after they had won the tournament, because it seemed as if everything was going well with Amir finally pleasing Baba.
Only after reading chapter seven did I realize that Hassan’s sacrifice to Assef out of loyalty to Amir was foreshadowed. The whole time Amir and Hassan had been growing up, Hassan never once put himself before Amir. Not even when Amir tests his obedience by asking Hassan if he would eat dirt if Amir wanted him to; and Amir knew he was genuine when he answered, “If you asked, I would.”
As this section progressed, I began dislike Amir. Every time Amir lied about Hassan being ill and therefore unable to join Baba and him at the lake, Jalalabad, or the cinema that sentiment grew against Amir. Ali said there was a brotherhood between them since they were nursed by the same woman. I found it greatly disappointing the way Hassan unconditionally tended to his brother’s every need, while Amir would not call Hassan his friend, nor ask Hassan to join his other friends in a game, nor admit to Hassan even being just his friend. After all they had been through together, Amir was still able to look at Hassan as a servant, a Hazara, a Shi’a Muslim, an inferior to himself. This is partially Afghanistan’s hierarchy’s fault, but I blame Amir mostly because they are not mere strangers, they have a close bond that Amir consciously neglects.
Sunday, September 21, 2008
An intriguing beginning...
Interesting as it may be, I found that the beginning of the book was rather slow. I felt however the transformation of Amir finding that his “Hazara” friend is not much as a friend as he would like it to be, quite a compelling part of the story. Even though it’s a very emotional yet rational part of the novel, I like how Hosseini intertwines the many different scenes of how things between two worlds that are completely unlike come together. I found that the loyalty being made from Hassan to Amir was something beyond just a friendship, but perhaps Hosseini meant to make an alter motive as to say that Amir is his superior as well as well as his friend. Ali I think could have a role in this, from the fact that even though Baba and Ali are friends. Ali STILL shows Baba the proper respect of a lesser almost inferior race through his humble service and life style in the “shack”.
I still don’t know what to make of Rahim Khan. It seems to me he means well, and that he shows the change much like the change in
As graphic as the rape scene to Hassan may be, I’m glad it was there. To enforce how real the situation of how badly the Hazara were treated. The insults made to Hassan and his father Ali give us a peep hole to the truth, that Amir is obviously able to see but not truly able to understand. Its interesting, how Hassan though he be harassed and beaten and even raped. Gives a sense of very cold “calmness” about him in all of the times he is insulted for his race. I like how Hosseini was able to interpret the look of the sheep for Hassan before he was “abused”. The look of the sheep before death shows the picture of peace in the eyes through innocence. The sheep doesn’t know of WHY it is being killed simply that he IS being killed and that is all he knows. Amir after the rape thus (obviously) is not dead thus he becomes deeply touched and more mature from the incident. Of not only why he is treated that way but how the world will see/treat him in future. Amir seeing cruelty tries to deny the incident through hiding, while Hassan simply tries to patch things up.
I felt things were starting to heat up with Amir’s birthday party, and Amir’s guilt in acting towards Hassan by the pomegranate tree. This has been quite an exciting yet informational book to the tradition and ways of Afghan life. I’m still reading and look forward to posting (my comments)/reading more of your guy’s comments in the future!
Word Count: 568
Pages 1-100 Response
First I would like to start off by saying that this book is awesome. I was skeptical at first, but I was most certainly proven wrong. Khaled Hosseini is a master storyteller and I can feel the emotions and struggles of Amir as he lives out the painful memories of a distant childhood. I really feel that the strongest part of this book is the character interactions between Amir and the different people that make up his life, especially Hassan. Amir’s relationship with Hassan is a great example of how society can overrule individuality and change how people truly think. We can see that Amir struggles within himself to try to find out if Hassan is his equal or merely his servant. Deep down, Amir loves Hassan the same either way , but it is interesting to see him fight what he knows is right in his heart, that Hassan is his best friend and “brother” and cannot live without him, and what society tells him, that Hassan is simply a Hazara servant and is merely there to make Amir’s life easier. Because of this indecision Hassan’s unwavering loyalty makes Amir feel like he is constantly lying around Hassan. I believe Amir’s relationship with Baba is the reason that he and Hassan never truly get closer. Amir is constantly trying to prove himself to Baba because he feels responsible for the death of his mother, and only wants his father’s love and approval. He wants to be seen as special in his father’s eyes, just like every boy does. This lack of approval creates a hole in Amir’s heart that causes him to do things he shouldn’t. All of this said the most important part of the book is of course what happens to Hassan. When reading this section I was filled with emotions, I almost felt like I was their in that alley, but I was not scared as Amir was, but rather angry. If it had been me in the alley and Assef had tried to rape one of my friends, I probably would have tried to kill him. I was beyond angry as I read and Amir did nothing. He truly let his cowardice rule over him, and let society win. Assef is bigot and a racist, and is the reason that the human race is failing at life right now. He is pure evil, and that simply fact that anyone could even do what Assef did, makes me sick. I honestly think that if I was Amir I would have tried to kill him in that alley. Amir’s choice will haunt him for the rest of his life, but I hope he comes out and tells someone and confronts his nightmares or it will only get worse. Rahim Khan would be the person Amir should tell because he understands Amir in a way that Baba doesn’t, but the way he should. Amir doesn’t realize it, but Rahim Khan can be the father he has been looking for his entire life, if only Amir would open up to him. This book has been intensely interesting so far, so instead continuing on with the amazing blog, I think ill go to my room and read some more.
word count 539
Nick's musings
Word count: 413
Saturday, September 20, 2008
First Blog
Wow. As this is the first blog post on The Kite Runner, I have to say I am thoroughly enjoying this book. It is doing an excellent job of painting a clear picture of what life in Afghanistan was like, and I am finding the concept of the social classes and the words of the other language slipped in to be enhancing my opinion of the book. The character development is kind of complex. I like the way it doesn’t actually just flat out tell you what each of the characters is like, but rather, it shows you in the way they treat other people, and the way their thoughts work. The book shows you what Baba is like in how he treats Amir. It shows you what Ali is like in the way he is loyal to the family, and cares about Hassan and Amir. It shows you what Rahim Khan is like in how he treats Amir kindly and truly tries to understand him. I have a like for most of the characters, but Amir makes me curious. How does he really feel about his father not giving him much attention? He gets so jealous of Hassan and wants so much attention from his father that he would go so incredibly far simply to just get that attention. True, I understand him being proud of winning the kite competition, but why would he go so far as to not rescue his friend from a torture such as rape? How could he forget, simply because he wanted attention from his father, and because social classes would’ve said otherwise, that he needed to do something in that situation? But the story has definitely pulled me into the heart of each character and makes me want to continue reading. I just can’t help but wonder, how does Hassan feel? It paints a picture of Afghanistan that makes me more compassionate. I’ve realized that things like this really do happen (even if this is just a book) and it makes me curious to see what else is going to happen to the characters in this book. I really am enjoying this book, however, and have already continued reading.
Word Count: 366
Wednesday, September 17, 2008
What shocked me in the first eight chapters in the way people treat Hassan and when he is raped. To me, that was something totally unexpected, and just to treat a human being like that, like a toy for fun, I believe is wrong. Also, that scene also shows how loyal Hassan is to Amir, and Amir takes him for granted but does not realize that until he no longer has someone to talk to. Amir and Baba’s relationship is based on how successful Amir is and not on his personality or even the fact that Amir is his son. I understand Baba might be upset at Amir for “killing” his wife, but it wasn’t Amir’s fault. Amir is jealous that Hassan gets treated the same as him, and he has done nothing to earn it. Amir is selfish but he wants to wants to make his father proud and will do anything to get the love he wants.
Also, Amir, at the beginning of the story was a somewhat normal boy, who had a servant who he considered a friend or someone who was just always there for him. But the whole relationship changed once Hassan got raped trying to do something for his “best friend”. But Amir was selfish and did not tell anyone about it or try to help Hassan, because he was afraid of what would happen to him. I was disgusted in Amir’s actions and I hope he proves to be a better person as the book continues.
To tell you the truth, I can’t put this book down. I really enjoy the book and I can’t wait to read more! =]
Word Count: 408
First Blog (pgs. 1-100)
At the beginning, I felt sorry for Amir. He seemed like he didn’t know where he fit in, and desperately wanted to please Baba. You could tell that Amir was very jealous of Hassan, but couldn’t help but like him. Hassan is such a sweet, loyal kid, and no one could help but like him. He was always there to back Amir up, and was always on his side.
Another character I really like is Rahim Khan. He seems more sensitive than Baba, and understands Amir. Rahim Khan always tries to make Amir feel appreciated, and like he did something right. When Amir wrote a story and Baba completely blew it off, Rahim Khan was there to read it, and praised Amir on how good of a writer he was. He also knew that Amir loved to write, and got him a notebook to write stories in for his birthday. Rahim Khan just seems like an all around good guy.
Amir seemed like he was a good person at first, but now I’m starting to think differently of him. He saw his best friend get raped and beat up, and didn’t say anything to anyone. To make it worse, Hassan got tortured because he was protecting Amir’s kite. I don’t know how Amir can live with himself. Hassan was always there to stick up for Amir, always willing to do whatever made Amir happy. He gets beat up, and his so-called “best friend” doesn’t say anything to anyone; not to Baba who’s one of the biggest and well-known men in their town, not to Hassan’s dad who’s pretty much family, not even to the kids who beat up Hassan. I think that Amir is a coward, and just not a good person. I hope eventually Amir will tell someone what happened and him and Hassan will become friends again.
Word Count: 351 <-- (do I need this??)
Wednesday, September 10, 2008
ASSIGNMENT
By midnight of Sun. Sept. 21 read through page 100 (chapter 8) and write one 200-word blog. After everyone has posted, you need to write a 100-word blog response to one of the postings sometime before midnight of Wed. Sept. 24.
By midnight of Sun. Sept. 28 read through page 227 (chapter 18) and write one 200-word blog. After everyone has posted, you need to write a 100-word blog response to one of the postings by midnight on Wed. Oct. 1.
By midnight of Sun. Oct. 5 read through the end and write one 200-word blog. After everyone has posted, you need to write a 100-word blog response to one of the postings by midnight on Wed. Oct. 8.
Remember this is the minimum. Feel free to respond to more than one posting.
ENJOY!