Sunday, September 28, 2008

Section 2

This book just keeps on getting better and better. This section was full of surprises and my feelings changed rapidly through the section. My feelings towards Amir went from complete hatred when he forced out Ali and Hassan, to sympathetic when Baba died. This section really showed us who Baba really was from him willing to die for the woman in the truck, to helping Amir get married in his last days of life. I still can’t believe that Hassan is Amir’s brother. Had Amir known I think he would have helped in the alley that day, and it could have avoided all the childhood problems that Amir had with Hassan. My feelings have changed toward Baba too, now that I know that he had Hassan as an illegitimate child. In one respect it better justifies his attachment to Hassan and helps me better understand his actions, but at the same time it makes think down upon him for not telling Amir, even when Baba knew he was going to die. I’m glad that Amir finally went back to Afghanistan (well Pakistan so far) and saw Rahim Khan. He definitely has some unresolved issues that he needs to take care of so he can have some peace in his life. I’m glad that Amir has a wife and is living a great life in America, but I hope that he takes this opportunity to right the wrongs of his past. I look forward to reading the rest of the book.



Word Count 250

1 comment:

Anonymous said...

I think you are on to something here. If Amir would have known that Hassan was his brother growing up, I think their whole childhood would have been different. Perhaps Amir would have fought some of his own battles because Hassan could be treated as his equal. Hassan would not have had the loyalty to Amir either, being a brother rather than servant, and therefore may have given up the last kite. Amir, having developed skills with Hassan in fights, may have been able to stand by Hassan’s side and defend their rightfully earned kite. I think Amir is almost just as selfish as he was growing up when Rahim Khan asks him to go get his nephew. Even though his excuses are more legitimate this time, I think there would be no question as to whether he should go save his nephew from an orphanage in a civil war. Regardless of his past, it should have been an automatic “yes”, but even with considering atonement for his past, he still denies the plea. Beyond just retrieving Sohrab, it would seem obvious that Amir and Soraya should take him into their home. I think, even a couple with children would adopt their nephew if they were the closest family he has. Amir should contact Soraya immediately to make this proposal to her. Sohrab is not like any other kid they would adopt, but he is family.