Monday, September 22, 2008

Section One Thoughts

When I read the first chapter I expected the winter of 1975 to be the start of violence in Afghanistan. I thought Amir’s thoughts supported that when he reflects on Hassan saying “For you, a thousand times over” and Rahim Khan saying “There is a way to be good again.” I thought Hassan may have sacrificed himself for Amir to escape to safety in the violence and Rahim was referring to doing something for Hassan’s family in appreciation of Hassan saving Amir’s life.
After finishing this section, I guess I was not that far off. I was wrong about the winter of 1975 being the start of war since the only violence of the sort was the coup d’état in chapter five, which was not to the magnitude I had expected. But Hassan’s sacrifice is just in a different form than I had expected it. Once chapter six started mentioning the kite fighting tournaments and the life-changing winter of 1975 that Amir had been leading up to, I was fairly confused. Amir spoke of the kite fighting as joyous times and a companionship with Hassan. Whereas the references to the winter of 1975 were all melancholy and filled with regret. These two concepts did not seem to have any relation to each before the tournament. I was still in the dark when Hassan recited the phrase that haunted Amir after they had won the tournament, because it seemed as if everything was going well with Amir finally pleasing Baba.
Only after reading chapter seven did I realize that Hassan’s sacrifice to Assef out of loyalty to Amir was foreshadowed. The whole time Amir and Hassan had been growing up, Hassan never once put himself before Amir. Not even when Amir tests his obedience by asking Hassan if he would eat dirt if Amir wanted him to; and Amir knew he was genuine when he answered, “If you asked, I would.”
As this section progressed, I began dislike Amir. Every time Amir lied about Hassan being ill and therefore unable to join Baba and him at the lake, Jalalabad, or the cinema that sentiment grew against Amir. Ali said there was a brotherhood between them since they were nursed by the same woman. I found it greatly disappointing the way Hassan unconditionally tended to his brother’s every need, while Amir would not call Hassan his friend, nor ask Hassan to join his other friends in a game, nor admit to Hassan even being just his friend. After all they had been through together, Amir was still able to look at Hassan as a servant, a Hazara, a Shi’a Muslim, an inferior to himself. This is partially Afghanistan’s hierarchy’s fault, but I blame Amir mostly because they are not mere strangers, they have a close bond that Amir consciously neglects.

3 comments:

Anonymous said...

Just in case I was supposed to include it (and since everyone else did) my word count was 468 words.

Julie B said...

Robert, I definitely would have to agree with you on a few things. I began to dislike Amir in this section because of the way he treated Hassan, but I also believe that it began to just barely reach character development. We saw this small time period with one bad decision in Amir's life; you have to remember that he was only twelve and that the winter of 1975 was a very trying situation for him. Although many of us view it as a bad choice on Amir's part, we have to remember that if we were in his shoes, it might've been the same in our cases. It’s a hard concept to imagine being in that situation.

Word Count: 118

Humph said...

Yeah, I agree with Julie Bob. Amir is certainly beginning to show what his father had said about Amir being weak and having others to fight his battles. I personally think that may have been wrong to watch but he should have manned up to his crime rather than hide and punish Hassan for it. Though the winter of 1975 was tough, and he indeed was 12. A boy becomes a man when he forces himself to see the cruelty the world makes around him. The moment he knew it was wrong, was that moment of becoming. He should have acted. Amir conciseness of his choice or not, I felt should have least come clean to his father, for his ignorance to his BEST friend.