Sunday, September 21, 2008

An intriguing beginning...

Interesting as it may be, I found that the beginning of the book was rather slow.  I felt however the transformation of Amir finding that his “Hazara” friend is not much as a friend as he would like it to be, quite a compelling part of the story. Even though it’s a very emotional yet rational part of the novel, I like how Hosseini intertwines the many different scenes of how things between two worlds that are completely unlike come together. I found that the loyalty being made from Hassan to Amir was something beyond just a friendship, but perhaps Hosseini meant to make an alter motive as to say that Amir is his superior as well as well as his friend. Ali I think could have a role in this, from the fact that even though Baba and Ali are friends. Ali STILL shows Baba the proper respect of a lesser almost inferior race through his humble service and life style in the “shack”.

I still don’t know what to make of Rahim Khan. It seems to me he means well, and that he shows the change much like the change in Afghanistan. He evidently gives his kindness to imagination and liberation from traditional boy values that are placed on Amir from Baba. Baba seems to support competitiveness and “boy” values, yet keep honor and a sense of family towards the Hazara. To me, this gave the impression of what the better half of Afghanistan was like. Who believed old tradition should remain, yet equal respect is necessary to keep the peace. This is bond of peace is shattered when Assef is given the chance to open Amirs eyes to the raw truth that the rest of the Afghanistan brings more than just change (like we see in Rahim Khan) but also brings chaos.

As graphic as the rape scene to Hassan may be, I’m glad it was there. To enforce how real the situation of how badly the Hazara were treated. The insults made to Hassan and his father Ali give us a peep hole to the truth, that Amir is obviously able to see but not truly able to understand. Its interesting, how Hassan though he be harassed and beaten and even raped. Gives a sense of very cold “calmness” about him in all of the times he is insulted for his race. I like how Hosseini was able to interpret the look of the sheep for Hassan before he was “abused”. The look of the sheep before death shows the picture of peace in the eyes through innocence. The sheep doesn’t know of WHY it is being killed simply that he IS being killed and that is all he knows. Amir after the rape thus (obviously) is not dead thus he becomes deeply touched and more mature from the incident. Of not only why he is treated that way but how the world will see/treat him in future. Amir seeing cruelty tries to deny the incident through hiding, while Hassan simply tries to patch things up.

I felt things were starting to heat up with Amir’s birthday party, and Amir’s guilt in acting towards Hassan by the pomegranate tree. This has been quite an exciting yet informational book to the tradition and ways of Afghan life. I’m still reading and look forward to posting (my comments)/reading more of your guy’s comments in the future!

Word Count: 568

1 comment:

Lauren Rife said...

Very good ideas Humph (hahah I like the display name) and I agree with you about the rape scene. When I first read it, I couldn’t believe it really happened and why didn’t Amir react and try to help his “friend”? It was necessary to put that in there, but it gave me a glimpse into how Amir really felt about Hassan and how society treats him.
On the other hand, the beginning of the book was slower then the rest, but it wasn’t unbearably slow. I though it was necessary to set the scene and give us some clues of what happened in his past.